| Alabama Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Alabama | Alabama | Varies |
| Alaska Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Alaska | Alaska | Varies |
| American Samoa Appellate Court / retention | Varies | American Samoa | American Samoa | Varies |
| Arizona Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Arizona | Arizona | Varies |
| Arkansas Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Arkansas | Arkansas | Varies |
| California Appellate Court / retention | Varies | California | California | Varies |
| Colorado Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Colorado | Colorado | Varies |
| Connecticut Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Connecticut | Connecticut | Varies |
| Delaware Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Delaware | Delaware | Varies |
| District of Columbia Appellate Court / retention | Varies | District of Columbia | District of Columbia | Varies |
| Florida Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Florida | Florida | Varies |
| Georgia Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Georgia | Georgia | Varies |
| Guam Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Guam | Guam | Varies |
| Hawaii Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Hawaii | Hawaii | Varies |
| Idaho Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Idaho | Idaho | Varies |
| Illinois Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Illinois | Illinois | Varies |
| Indiana Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Indiana | Indiana | Varies |
| Iowa Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Iowa | Iowa | Varies |
| Kansas Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Kansas | Kansas | Varies |
| Kentucky Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Kentucky | Kentucky | Varies |
| Louisiana Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Louisiana | Louisiana | Varies |
| Maine Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Maine | Maine | Varies |
| Maryland Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Maryland | Maryland | Varies |
| Massachusetts Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Massachusetts | Massachusetts | Varies |
| Michigan Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Michigan | Michigan | Varies |
| Minnesota Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Minnesota | Minnesota | Varies |
| Mississippi Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Mississippi | Mississippi | Varies |
| Missouri Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Missouri | Missouri | Varies |
| Montana Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Montana | Montana | Varies |
| Nebraska Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Nebraska | Nebraska | Varies |
| Nevada Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Nevada | Nevada | Varies |
| New Hampshire Appellate Court / retention | Varies | New Hampshire | New Hampshire | Varies |
| New Jersey Appellate Court / retention | Varies | New Jersey | New Jersey | Varies |
| New Mexico Appellate Court / retention | Varies | New Mexico | New Mexico | Varies |
| New York Appellate Court / retention | Varies | New York | New York | Varies |
| North Carolina Appellate Court / retention | Varies | North Carolina | North Carolina | Varies |
| North Dakota Appellate Court / retention | Varies | North Dakota | North Dakota | Varies |
| Northern Mariana Islands Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Northern Mariana Islands | Northern Mariana Islands | Varies |
| Ohio Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Ohio | Ohio | Varies |
| Oklahoma Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Oklahoma | Oklahoma | Varies |
| Oregon Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Oregon | Oregon | Varies |
| Pennsylvania Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Pennsylvania | Pennsylvania | Varies |
| Puerto Rico Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Puerto Rico | Puerto Rico | Varies |
| Rhode Island Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Rhode Island | Rhode Island | Varies |
| South Carolina Appellate Court / retention | Varies | South Carolina | South Carolina | Varies |
| South Dakota Appellate Court / retention | Varies | South Dakota | South Dakota | Varies |
| Tennessee Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Tennessee | Tennessee | Varies |
| Texas Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Texas | Texas | Varies |
| U.S. Virgin Islands Appellate Court / retention | Varies | U.S. Virgin Islands | U.S. Virgin Islands | Varies |
| Utah Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Utah | Utah | Varies |
| Vermont Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Vermont | Vermont | Varies |
| Virginia Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Virginia | Virginia | Varies |
| Washington Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Washington | Washington | Varies |
| West Virginia Appellate Court / retention | Varies | West Virginia | West Virginia | Varies |
| Wisconsin Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Wisconsin | Wisconsin | Varies |
| Wyoming Appellate Court / retention | Varies | Wyoming | Wyoming | Varies |